O. J. Simpson – $3 Million

Before 1994, O. J. Simpson, aka The Juice, was best known as a football star with the Buffalo Bills. He earned a grisly reputation upon becoming a suspect in the death of his former wife, Nicole Brown Simpson. The case immediately turned into a media spectacle.

He was acquitted in 1995 but was found liable by a civil court jury two years later. He ended up serving time for another crime, though. Simpson was arrested for armed robbery in 2007 but got out early on parole. As of 2020, he lives in Las Vegas and keeps a low profile.